Deportation Cases Spark Debate About Role of Judiciary in Foreign Affairs

Ongoing battles over the legality of the Trump administration’s deportations of illegal immigrants have fostered conditions for a constitutional showdown questioning where judicial authority ends and the executive’s begins.
In Washington, U.S. District Judge James Boasberg has suggested that in order for the administration to avoid being held in criminal contempt, it should reassert custody over at least some of those deported individuals. Meanwhile, Paula Xinis, a federal judge in Maryland, has similarly indicated the administration could be held in contempt for not facilitating the return of one of those detainees, Kilmar Abrego Garcia, to the United States….